Below is a joint press release from the National Audubon Society and
the Sierra Club in response to Corps workshops which start this week.
I urge any of you to attend these workshops if possible (workshop
dates are at the end).
Jane Clark
[log in to unmask]
------------------------------------------------
CONSERVATIONISTS URGE MORATORIUM ON ANY EXPANSION
OF COMMERCIAL NAVIGATION ON MISSISSIPPI AND ILLINOIS RIVERS; RELEASE
REPORT REBUTTING BARGE INDUSTRY'S CLAIMS OF FUEL EFFICIENCY
Conservationists are calling for a moratorium on any expansion of the
locks and dams on the Mississippi and Illinois rivers, and are
challenging the claim that barges are the most fuel-efficient means to
transport corn and soybeans from the Corn Belt to foreign markets.
In a "Conservation Agenda" released Monday, the conservationists
stress that a moratorium would save taxpayers at least $1.2 billion in
federal funds that the barge industry wants to spend to expand the
lock and dam system. They also urge Congress to direct federal
officials to undertake a first-time, comprehensive study of the
cumulative environmental effects caused by the existing commercial
navigation system.
The Army Corps of Engineers, which operates the system, has denied
conservationists' requests that it undertake such an environmental
study. Instead, the Corps has spent more than $54 million over the
last six years to determine how to speed and increase barge traffic on
the two Midwest rivers.
"Expanding the navigation system will continue to degrade fish and
wildlife habitat along the rivers and will not benefit American
farmers," said Dan McGuiness, who heads the National Audubon Society's
Upper Mississippi River Campaign. "Conservationists are not foes of
farmers, but we fail to see how subsidizing commercial navigation will
help them."
Also on Monday, the Sierra Club released a study by Iowa State
University economics researchers which challenges the argument that
barges are the most fuel-efficient means of transporting corn and
soybeans. That argument is a key part of the barge industry's
campaign for a huge, taxpayer-subsidized expansion of the locks and
dams.
The new study, which updates a 1985 study financed by the Iowa
Department of Transportation and the Iowa Corn Promotion Board, was
headed by Professor C. Phillip Baumel. The new study concludes that
rail is the most fuel-efficient means of shipping corn and soybeans
from central and western Iowa to U.S. seaports for sale to either
Europe or Japan. That conclusion would be equally true for shipping
grain from most origins in the Corn Belt, the study found.
"This study effectively rebuts the industry's claims that its barges
are the most fuel-efficient mode of transportation," said Carl
Zichella, the Sierra Club's Midwest regional staff director. "The
inland waterway system is heavily subsidized by American taxpayers,
giving the big corporations that own barges an unfair economic
advantage over rail and truck transport."
The Sierra Club is allied with the Audubon Society and other
conservation groups in opposing the industry's campaign to move barges
faster by lengthening five locks on the Upper Mississippi and two on
the Illinois River. Among the major barge owners are such profitable
agribusinesses as Cargill, Archer Daniels Midland (ADM) and ConAgra.
Their campaign is headed by a political lobbying and propaganda
organization, the Midwest Area Rivers Coalition 2000, or MARC 2000.
Numerous scientific studies have shown that the locks and dams have
seriously damaged the ecological health of the two Midwest rivers.
Expanding the navigation system to allow more barge traffic --
potentially doubling the volume of barge traffic -- would compound the
damage.
The Corps of Engineers is holding workshops in seven Midwest cities to
provide the public with its various alternative plans for speeding and
increasing barge traffic. Conservationists are urging the public to
attend the workshops, and to voice opposition to using federal funds
to continue subsidizing the corporations that control the barge
industry.
The workshops, which start at 6 p.m., are at these dates and
locations:
Thurs., July 29: BETTENDORF, IA. Belmont Building, Scott Community
College, 500 Belmont Rd.
Tues., Aug. 3: DES MOINES, IA. Des Moines Botanical Center, 909 E.
River Dr.
Weds., Aug. 4: LA CROSSE, WIS. Morris Hall, University of
Wisconsin-La Crosse.
Thurs., Aug. 5: INVER GROVE HEIGHTS, MN. Inver Hills Community
College, Liberal Arts Building, 2500 80th St. East.
For more information, please contact:
-- Upper Mississippi River Campaign, National Aubudon Society, 25 East
Exchange St., Suite 215, St. Paul, MN 55101 phone: (651)-290-1695
fax: (651)-225-4686 e-mail: [log in to unmask]
-- Midwest Office, the Sierra Club, 214 North Henry St., Suite 203,
Madison, WI. 53703-2200
phone: (608)-257-4994 fax: (608)-257-3513 e-mail:
[log in to unmask]
Sierra Club, Mississippi River Protection Program, Regional
Representatives:
-- Illinois, Iowa and Missouri: Mark Beorkrem (217)-526-4480
[log in to unmask]
-- Minnesota and Wisconsin: Dean Rebuffoni (612)-920-9632
[log in to unmask]
-----------------------------------------------------------------
To get off the IOWA-TOPICS list, send any message to:
[log in to unmask]
|