WASHINGTON (Crain’s) — The Energy Department is
pulling the plug on the FutureGen project, an experimental,
$1.75-billion, super-clean coal-fired power plant slated for
Downstate Mattoon.
The stunning decision, announced by Energy Secretary Sam Bodman
in a rancorous meeting with Illinois lawmakers Tuesday morning,
comes little more than a month after Illinois won a heated national
competition to host the project and one day after President George
W. Bush mentioned the technology in his State of the Union speech.
“After our meeting today, it is clear that Secretary of Energy
Sam Bodman has misled the people of Illinois, creating false hope in
a FutureGen project which he has no intention of funding or
supporting,” Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill., said in a statement. “In
25 years on Capitol Hill, I have never witnessed such a cruel
deception.”
The secretary personally presented his decision behind closed
doors to state officials and the Illinois congressional delegation,
which had called the meeting to find out why DOE was dragging its
feet on the project's environmental impact statement.
Three years after he became secretary of Energy, Mr. Bodman told
the lawmakers that "he didn't believe in the project," according to
a Capitol Hill source familiar with the discussion. "It's something
I inherited but not something I believe in," the source said,
paraphrasing what the secretary said at the meeting.
"We are committed to advancing FutureGen's important objectives
and are ensuring the appropriate due diligence in pursuing a
restructured approach that maximizes technological advances over the
past five years and harnesses private sector innovation, facilitates
the most productive public-private partnership, and prevents further
cost escalation," an Energy Department spokeswoman says in a
statement. "We plan to announce details in the coming days." She
declined to comment on what Mr. Bodman told the delegation.
FutureGen is designed to use coal gasification, a technology that
burns cleanly but still produces carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas
that contributes to global warming. Its critical technology would
capture the carbon dioxide and pump it deep into the ground,
trapping it in layers of sandstone.
Doubts about the project cropped up in December, soon after the
industry consortium backing the project decided on Mattoon, beating
out another Downstate site and two in Texas.
Energy Department officials refused to issue a final
environmental clearance report, citing the project’s escalating
costs. Under their agreement, industrial partners were expected to
put up about $400 million, with the federal government picking up
the rest.
“Today’s meeting was a disappointment but not a surprise,” says
Frederick Palmer, a lobbyist for St. Louis-based Peabody Energy Co.,
one of the industry partners in the FutureGen Alliance. “It’s clear
to us that DOE wanting to renegotiate was not true — they wanted a
path out of the project.”
After Energy Department officials raised concerns about the
costs, the FutureGen Alliance made a counteroffer to go forward with
the project, but DOE never responded to that, according to Mr.
Palmer, who thinks the project can still go forward if it is
directly approved and funded by Congress.
“The Illinois Congressional delegation is going to make the case
for FutureGen directly to the president,” Sen. Durbin said in his
statement. “We will not go down without a fight.” Gov. Rod
Blagojevich said in a statement, "The U.S. Secretary of Energy's
proposal to dismantle FutureGen is an example of politics at its
worst. Secretary Samuel Bodman is not only jeopardizing the benefits
FutureGen promises to deliver, but he deceived the people of East
Central Illinois who spent time and resources competing for the
project. We're not giving up the fight to make FutureGen a reality
in Illinois.”