http://www.motherearthnews.com/Nature-Community/Colony-Collapse-Pesticides-Bees.aspx
Colony
Collapse: Are Potent Pesticides Killing Honeybees?
With a third of honeybee
colonies disappearing due to “colony collapse
disorder,” it’s time to move
into high gear to find a solution.
October/November 2009
By Amanda
Kimble-Evans
Two common pesticides are being linked to colony collapse
disorder
symptoms in honeybees.
EDITED
Now the EPA is being sued by
the nonprofit Natural Resources Defense
Council (NRDC) for withholding
details about the impact of
neonicotinoids — a class of widely used
pesticides — on honeybees and
other pollinators.
While Bayer
CropScience, the primary producer of both pesticides,
maintains honeybee
deaths reported in Europe were caused by unusual
application errors, they
don’t dispute the proven toxicity of their
products. Instead, they maintain
bees do not encounter enough of an
exposure to cause harm. Now even that
assertion is under the
microscope.
A report by Maryann Frazier, senior
extension associate at
Pennsylvania State University, points to a new study
from Italy
suggests honeybees may be ingesting neonicotinoids at levels
1,000
times higher than that in pollen or nectar via water
droplets
expressed from the leaves of corn grown from the
pesticide-coated
seed. This “guttation water” is a common source of liquid
for forager
bees. The concentrations in the droplets were high enough to kill
bees
within five minutes of consumption.
Frazier also highlights a
study from North Carolina University that
found the neonicotinoid Terraguard
and the fungicide Procure had
synergistic affects when combined, increasing
the danger of the
neonicotinoid to honeybees to over 1,000 times its original
toxicity.
The researchers at Penn State are concerned that even sub-lethal
doses
of these pesticides, while not killing the bees, are impairing
their
behavior and suppressing their immune systems.
“Their use has
increased dramatically over the past few years and they
are now the most
widely used group of insecticides in the United
States,” writes
Frazier.
As usage skyrockets, regulation lags behind. Clothianidin was
approved
in 2003 with the condition that Bayer must provide research on
the
chemical’s effects on honeybees. The EPA has received the
research,
but has yet to release all of it — despite requests from the
NRDC,
thus prompting the lawsuit. The EPA has also provided 163
emergency
exemptions for imidacloprid in 26 states, all with little to
no
research on the sub-lethal affects being reported by researchers
in
both the US and abroad. (Emergency exemptions allow unregistered use
of
a chemical for a limited period of time.)
Pesticide regulation loopholes
are making it nearly impossible to
track down the causes of colony collapse
disorder.